New Rules for Juror’s in Florida Civil and Criminal trials

In 1999 the Florida Legislature passed the Juror”s Bill of Rights, now codified as Florida Statute 40.50. In October of 2007, the Supreme Court of Florida adopted some of these “”rights”” and incorporated them into the Florida Rules of Procedure and the Florida Standard Jury Instructions. These Rules and Instructions will become effective January 1, 2008.
Some of these procedures are already being followed by Judges in Escambia, Santa Rosa and Okaloosa counties as well as other Florida courts. The following are some of the changes that provide jurors certain rights in Civil and Criminal trials.

Being able to take notes. Florida Statutes had previously allowed that in any civil trial likely to last more than five days, jurors have the right to take notes and keep their notes confidential. However, the new Rules implemented by the Florida Supreme Court extended this right to jurors in criminal cases as well as civil cases and removed the requirement that the trial last more than five days. This Rule will become effective January 1, 2008.

Jurors are now able, within the Court’s discretion, to be allowed to submit questions to the Judge to ask witnesses. The Florida Supreme Court again extended this right into criminal trials, it had existed in civil trials since 1999. In criminal cases, the new rule becomes effective January 1, 2008. It appears that a juror”s right to ask questions is mandatory in civil trials but only discretionary in criminal trials. Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.452 states the Court “”shall”” permit jurors to submit questions, whereas Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.371 states that “”at the discretion of the presiding trial judge””, jurors “”may”” be allowed to submit questions. It is not uncommon for some judges to actually ask questions of witnesses either during the questioning or once the state and defense have completed their questioning; this procedure is allowed as long as the judge does not make known to the jury his or her personal beliefs of the merits of the case into his or her questions.

In civil trials Jurors are required to be allowed to use notebooks provided them by the trial court. The Florida Supreme Court approved the use of “”juror notebooks”” in civil trials (effective Jan 1 2008 – in the discretion of the court). This is a procedure whereby “”the court may authorize documents and exhibits to be included in notebooks for use by jurors during trial to aid them in performing their duties.”” See Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.455. There is no counterpart to this rule in the criminal rules however often in Pensacola and other court rooms across the country judges give jurors notebooks on which to keep notes. These notebooks are collected after the trial and destroyed.

Jurors are now mandatorily given copies of jury instructions in civil cases. Effective January 1, 2008, the court shall provide each juror in a civil trial with a written set of jury instructions for his or her use during deliberations. See Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.470 and Florida Standard Jury Instruction Civil (Note On Use) 2.1.


2 responses to “New Rules for Juror’s in Florida Civil and Criminal trials”

  1. birdsongslaw says:

    I am glad to hear of these changes. But, tell me…why does it take so long for these changes to catch on with respect to criminal cases?

  2. Great – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your web site. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs and related info ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Nice task.. – Arch Design Window & Door Co, 108 May Drive, Harrison, Ohio, zip: 45030-2083, Phone: (513) 367-0737